The Hardware Man: Getting Ready for the Snow Season

Howdy Folks,
I really hate to say it, but we are getting ready for snow season. It has turned chill and we have reset our heaters to the front of the store and moved the summer products to storage. The truckload of salt arrived a couple weeks ago, and we are making space for the snow shovels. At home, I pulled out the snowplow and tuned up the snow blowers.
I have decided to keep doing commercial winter maintenance for a number of properties on Main Street in Zelienople. These are customers I have had for years, and they are comfortable with the level of service and price point. Still, given the sue-happy society we live in, we sign contracts and hope we never have to resort to the fine print.
It is frustrating how legalistic business has needed to become, but it is an effect of our society as a whole. Attorneys will point to Tort Reform from the 1970’s, when the laws adjusted to allow civil penalties for injury or wrongdoing. Now, someone can sue anyone and everyone for injury and woe to the one who can’t pay to fight it or settle. And so, we introduce Insurance, where we pay a company a sum of money to protect our assets.
Insurance companies, naturally, are in it to make money. So, if given a chance to not pay out, they will take it. Then, we introduce the lawyer to go to bat for us against the Insurance Company, who was hired to protect us as well as against the plaintiff who is suing us. They review our contracts and advocate in our defense against frivolous claims or negotiate a settlement the insurance company will support. It’s such a vicious cycle and raises prices with no real added day-to-day benefit.
Any business that has been in existence for any amount of time will be sued or need to file suit. There will be a claim, generally for work performed that wasn’t paid for or was unsatisfactory. It happens, and the basis of the claim will come down to what the contract says. Terms, conditions, scope of work are standard, then the legal fine print that that will make or break the case. Often, the break-even on defending a lawsuit is what the settlement amount will be, even when innocent or not at fault. I have been there, done that, and it is very frustrating.
Recently I have had separate conversations between contractors as well as an insurance broker. The contractors have both felt taken advantage of by their customers who take liberties to adjust payments based on their perception of quality of work done. Depending on the dollar amount owed, it may be simpler to call it good enough and leave, or to file in small claims court for the full amount and argue their case before a magistrate. Often these situations end up being a matter of documentation – what does the estimate, contract, paper trail and pictures say? The insurance broker was complaining about the increase in price in my winter maintenance contract. Of all people, should I explain to him why prices need to increase?
I miss the days when a handshake confirmed a deal, but unfortunately that era has mostly passed. I only handshake on small jobs with known customers now, and half the time I regret it. Everything else gets a contract, down payment, change orders and a certificate of insurance. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Fool me three times…
Daniel Karns and his wife own Clintonville Hardware & Rental along with other businesses. Join the discussion by contacting him at info@clintonvillehardware.com.



